🔍 Read the full analysis: Understanding The 18 Proposals To Test AI Chatbots In France on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get audio and creator gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
TL;DR
A French expert commission delivered 18 recommendations on AI assistants to President Emmanuel Macron’s office on November 10, including nine priorities. The proposals call for consumer chatbots to be tested before reaching the European market and checked regularly after launch, but they are not law and no bill or timetable had been identified by November 11.
A French expert commission has proposed 18 recommendations to regulate consumer AI assistants, including requiring chatbots to pass a safety evaluation before entering the European market and undergo checks after launch. The commission delivered its report to the Élysée, the office of President Emmanuel Macron, on November 10; the proposals are recommendations, not current law.
The report, titled Protect Without Preventing: Vulnerabilities in the Age of Generative AI, marks nine of its 18 recommendations as priorities. Its central proposal is that consumer chatbots and AI companions should reach the European market only after an evaluation finds they “neither exploit nor aggravate the vulnerabilities of their users.” The commission also proposes periodic checks after launch and says authorities could consider withdrawing a system if its provider fails to meet requirements.
The proposed checks would apply to consumer-facing systems, including chatbots built into social media platforms, rather than professional AI systems. The report suggests repeating evaluations every 12 to 24 months, after a substantial change to a model, or when an alert is raised. That interval is an example in the report, not an existing regulatory schedule.
Other recommendations target product design and user protections. They include restrictions on design that flatters users or makes an AI seem human to encourage dependence; measures for services accessible to minors; a ban on undisclosed commercial influence in AI answers; and rights for users over information chatbots infer about them. The commission also calls for prior approval for AI toys that use generative AI.
Testing Consumer AI Before Market Entry
A French expert commission proposed 18 recommendations for consumer AI assistants. They are not law, and no bill or timetable had been identified by November 11, 2026.
Who could be covered
The proposals focus on consumer facing AI products.
Consumer assistants
Would include chatbots built into social media platforms.
AI companions
Design limits aim to reduce dependence encouraged by flattery or human-like presentation.
AI-enabled toys
The commission proposes prior approval for toys using generative AI.
Proposed safety checks
The commission would make evaluation an ongoing part of consumer AI oversight.
Systems would need to show they neither exploit nor aggravate users’ vulnerabilities before entering the European market.
Checks could follow a substantial model change or an alert. Every 12 to 24 months is a suggested example, not an existing schedule.
Authorities could consider removing a system from the market if its provider fails to meet requirements.
Other proposed protections
- Measures for services accessible to minors.
- A ban on undisclosed commercial influence in AI answers.
- Rights over information chatbots infer about users.
- Limits on design that may encourage emotional dependence.
What happens next
The report is intended to inform France’s position on the EU AI Act and other European negotiations.
- Recommendations from an expert commission.
- No new provider restrictions from the report alone.
- Whether officials will take them forward.
- Which authority would conduct evaluations.
- Methods, appeals and any action timetable.
Proposed Checks Before Chatbots Launch
The proposal would shift oversight toward testing before market entry, rather than relying mainly on action after a product is available or harm has been reported. If adopted, that could affect how providers design, assess and update consumer assistants across Europe. The commission’s recommendation for recurring reviews would also make safety assessment an ongoing obligation, rather than a one-time step.
The report links its proposals to concerns about dependence, minors’ safety and commercial influence. It warns that conversational systems can encourage users to rely on them, while human-like presentation or flattery may foster emotional attachment. Its proposed safeguards could shape both the products users encounter and the information they receive about how those products make money.
For now, however, there is no new restriction on providers arising from this report alone. Most recommendations would require action at European Union level, according to the source material, so their effects depend on whether France and other EU institutions take them forward.
Products Worth Considering
Anker SOLIX C300 DC Portable Power Station with 60W Solar Panel, 288Wh, 300W
DJI Mini 4 Pro Fly More Combo Drone with DJI RC 2
LG UltraGear 27-inch QHD OLED Gaming Monitor, 240Hz
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Commission Reached Its Proposals
The commission, named IA générative et vulnérabilités (“Generative AI and Vulnerabilities”), was set up by France’s advisory Council on AI and Digital Technology, known as CIANum. The minister delegate for AI and digital affairs, Anne Le Hénanff, assigned the work to the council on February 20, 2026. The Élysée said nine multidisciplinary and independent experts took part, led by AI researcher Serena Villata and psychiatrists Raphaël Gaillard and Amine Benyamina.
According to the report, the experts held 55 hearings over four months with health professionals, researchers, companies, regulators and child-protection groups. The full report is 193 pages. The commission’s stated scope is consumer AI, including chatbots, AI companions and toys with AI built in; the Élysée says the core proposal does not target professional systems.
The report describes rapid adoption alongside public concerns about trust and use. It cites a figure of 33 million unique generative AI users in France at the start of 2026, as reported in the Élysée summary. It also cites a 2026 digital barometer finding that 26% of 12- to 17-year-olds use generative AI daily. These are figures from the surveys and sources identified in the report, not independent measures of the proposed rules’ effects.
““Neither exploit nor aggravate the vulnerabilities of their users.””
— The commission’s report
No Bill or Timetable Identified
The recommendations have not become law. As of November 11, the source material reported no bill and no timeline for government action. It is also unclear which recommendations the French government will support, how they might be written into EU rules, or whether the proposed evaluation and withdrawal powers would be adopted as described.
The report’s suggested checks every 12 to 24 months are an example, not a final standard. The available material also does not spell out the exact test methods, which authority would conduct or oversee assessments, how providers could challenge a decision, or what evidence would trigger a market withdrawal. Those details would depend on any legislation or regulatory process that follows.
EU Policy Discussions Will Shape Follow-Up
The report is intended to inform France’s position on updating the EU AI Act and on other European texts still under negotiation, according to the source material. The next step is political: French officials and EU institutions would need to decide whether to develop the recommendations into proposals and how to handle them in existing or forthcoming rules.
Until a legislative or regulatory step is announced, the 18 recommendations remain a framework proposed by an expert commission. Readers should watch for a government response, a timetable for EU discussions, and details on whether any proposed protections—particularly those for minors and pre-launch evaluations—will be taken forward.
Key Questions
What did the French commission propose?
It proposed 18 recommendations, nine marked as priorities, for consumer AI assistants. They include pre-launch evaluations, recurring checks, protections for minors, limits on design that may encourage dependence, and restrictions on undisclosed advertising.
Are the recommendations already law?
No. They are expert recommendations, not binding rules. As of November 11, the source material reported no bill or implementation timetable.
Which AI products would the proposed rules cover?
The report focuses on consumer chatbots, AI companions and AI-enabled toys, including chatbots built into social media platforms. The Élysée said the core proposal does not target professional systems.
Would chatbots have to be tested after launch?
Yes, under the commission’s proposal. It suggests periodic evaluations, giving every 12 to 24 months as an example, and checks after substantial model changes or alerts. That schedule is proposed, not in force.
What happens next?
The recommendations are intended to inform France’s position on the EU AI Act and other EU negotiations. Whether officials turn them into policy, and on what timetable, remains unknown.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
