Choosing the right house siding involves balancing durability, appearance, maintenance, and cost. The CertainTeed Cedar Impressions Double 7 Inch Straight Edge stands out as the best overall due to its realistic cedar look and low maintenance. For a more premium option, the GAF WeatherSide Emphasis Extra Thick Thatched Edge Fiber-Cement Siding offers superior durability and fire resistance. Meanwhile, the Polaris Homeside Select Vinyl Siding provides a budget-friendly, easy-to-install alternative. Each siding type presents tradeoffs: some prioritize longevity, others ease of installation or cost. Continue reading for a full breakdown of these options and what to consider when selecting your house siding.
Get audio and creator gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Fiber cement siding offers the best balance of durability and low maintenance, but generally comes with a higher price tag.
- Vinyl siding remains the most cost-effective and easiest to install, though it may sacrifice some realism and longevity.
- Realistic wood-look options, such as composite shakes, provide aesthetic appeal with less maintenance than natural wood.
- Fire-resistant and moisture-resistant materials are increasingly important for safety and longevity, especially in certain climates.
- Installation complexity varies widely; choosing a product suited to your skill level can affect long-term satisfaction and costs.
| house siding | Material |
|---|---|
| CertainTeed Cedar Impressions | Polymer |
| Cedar Impressions Double 9 Inc | Injection molded durable polymer |
| GAF WeatherSide Emphasis Extra | Fiber cement |
| GAF WeatherSide Purity Straigh | Fiber cement |
| Polaris Homeside Select Double | — |
| Tando Beach House Shake Compos | Composite |
| CertainTeed Monogram Horizonta | Vinyl |
| Tando Beach House Shake Compos | Composite |
| GAF WeatherSide Profile 9 Fibe | Fiber cement |
| CertainTeed Board and Batten V | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
CertainTeed Cedar Impressions Double 7 Inch Straight Edge Perfection Shingle Siding (1/2 Square)
This siding stands out for its authentic cedar shingle appearance, thanks to TrueTexture technology that convincingly mimics real woodgrain. Compared to vinyl options like the Polaris Homeside Select, it offers a more natural look and superior weather resistance, but at a higher initial cost and with some installation complexity. Its durable polymer construction resists fading and weather damage, making it a solid choice for homeowners seeking low-maintenance, lasting curb appeal. However, it may require professional installation to achieve perfect results, and color choices are somewhat limited. For those prioritizing authenticity with minimal upkeep, this pick delivers a premium appearance and durability.
Pros:- Authentic cedar appearance with TrueTexture technology
- High durability and weather resistance
- Fade-resistant color options
- Easy to install with fastener and nail indicators
Cons:- Requires professional installation for best results
- Higher initial cost compared to traditional vinyl siding
Best for: Homeowners wanting a high-end, realistic cedar look with long-term durability, willing to invest in quality.
Not ideal for: DIYers on a tight budget or with limited experience who prefer simpler, more forgiving installation processes.
- Panel Projection:3/4 Inch
- Width:14 inches
- Siding Thickness:.090 Inches
- Siding Length:47 Inches
- Pieces per Carton:11
- Coverage:50.26 Square Feet
- Material:Polymer
- Made in:USA
- Limited Lifetime Warranty:Yes
Our verdict“This siding makes the most sense for homeowners seeking a premium, realistic cedar look with long-lasting performance.”
Cedar Impressions Double 9 Inch Staggered Rough Split Shakes Mountain Cedar
This product excels in delivering a traditional cedar shake look, with a textured finish and wide color options that suit various architectural styles. Compared with the more detailed and textured CertainTeed Cedar Impressions, this vinyl siding offers easier installation and lower maintenance, but it sacrifices some of the nuanced realism. Its snap-together design simplifies installation, yet careful handling is needed to prevent damage. The 1-inch panel projection adds depth, making it suitable for those wanting a true shake aesthetic without the upkeep of real wood. For homeowners seeking a versatile, low-maintenance cedar shake with broad color choices, this product offers a compelling balance of appearance and practicality.
Pros:- Realistic cedar shingle appearance with textured finish
- Low maintenance and weather resistant
- Precise installation with fastening indicators
- Wide color selection for design flexibility
Cons:- Vinyl may not appeal to those seeking natural wood
- Installation requires careful handling due to snap-together design
Best for: Homeowners wanting a traditional cedar shake look with broad color options and easy maintenance.
Not ideal for: Purists who prefer natural wood or those avoiding vinyl siding due to material preferences.
- Design:Double 9 Inch, two 9 Inch sections snap together for 18 Inches
- Panel Projection:1 Inch
- Siding Thickness:.125 Inches
- Siding Length:57 Inches
- Siding Width:18 Inches
- Pieces per Carton:7
- Material:Injection molded durable polymer
- Made in:USA
- Weather Resistance:Resists damaging weather effects
Our verdict“Ideal for homeowners who want a traditional cedar shake appearance with minimal upkeep and flexible color choices.”
GAF WeatherSide Emphasis Extra Thick Thatched Edge Fiber-Cement Siding Shingles (14-5/8×25-5/32), 11 Bundles with Wood Grain Surface, Fire Resistant, Pre-Primed
This fiber cement siding offers an authentic vintage wood grain appearance with a thick thatched edge, standing out for its fire-resistant and durable construction. Unlike the vinyl options, this product provides a more realistic, textured surface that appeals to those aiming for a genuine wood or shingle look. It surpasses vinyl in durability, resisting warping, rotting, and UV damage, but its weight and installation complexity demand careful handling and potentially extra framing support. Pre-primed and ready for painting, it suits renovation projects that value safety and authenticity. For homeowners prioritizing fire safety and longevity over ease of installation, this fiber cement choice delivers a classic aesthetic with modern resilience.
Pros:- Authentic vintage wood grain appearance
- Fire-resistant and asbestos-free for safety
- Resists warping, rotting, UV, and termites
- Pre-primed and easy to paint for customization
Cons:- Heavy weight requiring additional support
- Limited color options unless painted
- Designed for specific siding applications
Best for: Homeowners needing a durable, fire-resistant siding with an authentic look, especially during renovations or new builds.
Not ideal for: DIYers seeking lightweight, quick-install siding or those on a tight budget due to weight and labor considerations.
- Size:14-5/8 x 25-5/32 inches
- Bundles:11
- Surface:Wood grain
- Material:Fiber cement
- Fire Resistance:UL Classified to ANS/UL723
- Asbestos-Free:Yes
Our verdict“Best suited for homeowners who want a vintage aesthetic combined with high safety and durability standards.”
GAF WeatherSide Purity Straight Fiber-Cement Siding Shingles (12×24), 18 Bundles
This fiber cement shingle siding provides a classic, vintage look similar to asbestos shingles, with the added benefits of modern safety and durability. It eclipses vinyl options like the Polaris Homeside in authenticity and fire resistance, but its weight and the need to remove existing siding make installation more involved. The pre-primed surface allows for customization, though it demands more labor and planning, especially for larger projects. Its textured surface convincingly mimics traditional shingles, making it a favorite for historic renovations. For homeowners who want a historically accurate, safe, and durable siding, this product offers a compelling combination of aesthetics and resilience.
Pros:- Authentic vintage appearance with textured surface
- Safe, asbestos-free, non-combustible
- Durable against warping, rot, UV, termites
- Pre-primed and customizable with paint
Cons:- Heavy weight complicates handling and installation
- Requires removal of existing siding before installation
- Limited color options unless painted
Best for: Homeowners restoring historic homes or seeking a durable, vintage-style siding with fire safety considerations.
Not ideal for: DIYers or those with limited labor resources, due to weight and prep requirements.
- Size:12×24 inches
- Bundles:18
- Material:Fiber cement
- Fire Resistance:UL Classified to ANS/UL723
- Asbestos-Free:Yes
Our verdict“Ideal for homeowners prioritizing safety, authenticity, and durability in vintage-style siding projects.”
Polaris Homeside Select Double 7in. Cedar Shake Vinyl Siding (1/2 Square) Savannah Wicker
This vinyl siding offers a convincing cedar shake look with textured detail, making it a budget-friendly alternative to fiber cement or natural wood. It features Tru-Lock technology for a seamless, secure fit, and comes backed by a limited lifetime warranty, which adds peace of mind. Compared to fiber cement options like GAF WeatherSide, it’s easier and quicker to install, but it’s heavier than other vinyl options, which could be a challenge for some installers. Its limited color options and the need for extra material due to waste make it less flexible for custom color matching. Overall, this pick suits those seeking the aesthetic of cedar shakes without the higher cost or maintenance associated with wood or fiber cement.
Pros:- Realistic cedar shake appearance with textured detail
- Low maintenance and weather-resistant
- Seamless Tru-Lock installation system
- Backed by a lifetime warranty
Cons:- Installation may require about 20% extra material
- Limited color options listed
- Heavy weight per box could pose handling challenges
Best for: Homeowners on a budget wanting a realistic cedar shake appearance with easy installation and low maintenance.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking the most authentic or highly customizable siding, or those preferring natural materials.
- Height:15-3/8 Inch
- Exposure:17 Inch
- Overall Width:48 inches
- Thickness:1/8 Inch
- Pieces per box:10
- Coverage per box:50 sq. feet
- Weight per box:37 pounds
Our verdict“Best suited for homeowners wanting a realistic cedar shake look without the expense of fiber cement or wood, and with straightforward installation.”
Tando Beach House Shake Composite Siding Panels – Pacifica Color – Cedar Shake Alternative Exterior Siding – Moisture Resistant, Low Maintenance – 1/2 Square Coverage
This composite siding excels in delivering the aesthetic of cedar shakes without the upkeep, outperforming traditional wood in moisture resistance and durability. Compared with the CertainTeed Board and Batten, it offers a more authentic shake look while requiring less maintenance. The lightweight design and ease of installation make it a practical choice for quick projects, but it does demand a starter strip and matching corner pieces, adding some prep work. If you want the charm of cedar with the resilience of modern materials, this pick stands out.
Pros:- Authentic cedar shake appearance without ongoing upkeep
- Highly resistant to moisture, cracking, and discoloration
- Lightweight and easy to install with standard tools
Cons:- Starter strip required for installation, sold separately
- May need matching corner pieces for a finished look
Best for: Homeowners seeking a low-maintenance, rustic exterior that mimics cedar shakes, especially in climates prone to moisture or pests.
Not ideal for: Buyers wanting a seamless, finished look without matching corner pieces or those uncomfortable with slightly more involved installation.
- Color:Pacifica
- Material:Composite
- Coverage:50 sq ft per box
- Panel Dimensions:42.63″ W x 15″ H
- Exposure:5″
- Coverage per carton:11 interlocking pieces
Our verdict“Ideal for those wanting the look of cedar shakes with minimal maintenance and high durability.”
CertainTeed Monogram Horizontal Vinyl Siding (2 Square) Double 5in. Dutchlap Colonial White
This vinyl siding offers a convincing wood-like appearance with a Dutchlap profile that mimics hand-carved cedar. Compared to the GAF WeatherSide Profile 9 fiber-cement shingles, it provides a cleaner, more traditional horizontal look suitable for residential homes. Its fade-resistant PermaColor technology ensures long-lasting color, but it comes at a higher cost and requires professional installation to achieve best results. If you prioritize a low-maintenance, realistic aesthetic that resists fading, this siding makes a strong case.
Pros:- Realistic cedar wood texture with low maintenance
- Fade-resistant PermaColor technology for lasting color
- Durable with wind load performance
Cons:- Limited color options, mainly Colonial White
- Requires professional installation for optimal appearance
- Generally higher price point compared to standard vinyl siding
Best for: Families wanting a durable, fade-resistant sidings that looks like real wood and prefers a horizontal profile.
Not ideal for: DIYers seeking a budget-friendly project, as professional installation is recommended and costs can be higher.
- Material:Vinyl
- Fire Rating:Class 1(A)
- Thickness:0.046in.
- Panel Length:12ft
- Profile:Double 5 Dutchlap
- Color:Colonial White
Our verdict“Best suited for homeowners desiring a long-lasting, realistic wood appearance with minimal upkeep.”
Tando Beach House Shake Composite Siding Panels – Hatteras Color – Cedar Shake Alternative Exterior Siding – Moisture Resistant, Low Maintenance – 1/2 Square Coverage
These composite panels replicate cedar shakes with remarkable resistance to moisture, cracking, and discoloration, making them suitable for challenging weather conditions. Unlike the GAF WeatherSide Shingles which are primarily for roofing, these panels focus on siding durability and ease of installation, especially in climates with high humidity or frequent storms. They require a starter strip and matching corners, which adds some complexity, but their lightweight nature speeds up installation. This choice is excellent for homeowners who want a shake aesthetic that withstands the elements.
Pros:- Authentic cedar shake appearance without ongoing maintenance
- Resistant to moisture, cracking, and discoloration
- Lightweight and quick to install, saving labor time
Cons:- Starter strip sold separately
- Requires matching corner pieces for a finished look
Best for: Homeowners in harsh, humid, or storm-prone areas seeking a low-maintenance shake look that endures weather extremes.
Not ideal for: Those preferring a traditional wood shake look or who want a seamless finish without matching corner pieces.
- Color:Hatteras
- Material:Composite
- Coverage:50 sq ft per box
- Dimensions:42.63″ W x 15″ H
- Exposure:5″
- Installation:Requires starter strip
Our verdict“Perfect for climates demanding durable, low-maintenance cedar shake alternatives in exterior siding.”
GAF WeatherSide Profile 9 Fiber-Cement Siding Shingles (9×32), 19 Bundle, Vertical Striated Surface, Fire Resistant, Pre-Primed, Durable, Easy to Install
The GAF WeatherSide Profile 9 shingles bring a textured, vintage vibe with their vertical striated surface, resembling traditional asbestos shingles but with modern, fire-resistant fiber-cement. Compared with the CertainTeed Monogram Vinyl Siding, these offer a more authentic, textured appearance, especially suited for historic or cottage-style homes. They are pre-primed, making painting straightforward, but their weight requires careful handling and proper installation techniques. Their fire resistance and durability make them a compelling choice for safety-conscious buyers seeking a classic look.
Pros:- Authentic textured, vintage shingle appearance
- Fire-resistant and asbestos-free for safety
- Durable, weather, pest, and UV resistant
Cons:- Requires painting after installation to achieve final color
- Heavy material demands careful handling and proper support
Best for: Owners of historic homes or those wanting an authentic vintage appearance combined with fire safety and durability.
Not ideal for: DIYers seeking lightweight siding or those who prefer a smooth, modern look over textured shingles.
- Size:9 x 32 inches
- Bundle Quantity:19 shingles
- Surface:Vertical striated
- Material:Fiber cement
- Fire Resistance:UL Classified, non-combustible
- Primed:Yes
Our verdict“Well-suited for those who prioritize safety, durability, and a historic aesthetic in their siding choice.”
CertainTeed Board and Batten Vertical Vinyl Siding – 12 ft, Colonial White, Single 8 Inch
This vinyl siding captures the classic board and batten style with a rough cedar finish, offering a maintenance-free exterior that withstands weather and pests. Compared to the GAF WeatherSide Emphasis fiber-cement shingles, it provides a more distinctive vertical, rustic look that suits farmhouses and modern interpretations alike. The 8-inch profile and various length options make it flexible for different projects, but its weight can be a challenge for DIY installations, and color choices are limited to Colonial White. For those seeking a traditional or modern take on vertical siding, this option balances appearance and longevity.
Pros:- Realistic rough cedar finish for authentic appearance
- Maintenance-free, never needs painting
- Durable PVC with fire-rated protection
Cons:- Limited color options, mainly Colonial White
- Heavyweight for some DIY applications
- Requires careful handling during installation
Best for: Homeowners wanting a durable, maintenance-free vertical siding with authentic board and batten aesthetics, especially for renovations or new builds.
Not ideal for: DIYers with limited strength or those needing a wide color palette, since options are restricted and handling can be heavy.
- Size:12 ft length
- Profile:Single 8 Inch
- Exposure:8 Inches
- Coverage:1 square (100 sq ft)
- Pieces per Carton:15
- Finish:Rough Cedar
Our verdict“An excellent choice for traditional vertical siding fans seeking durability and a realistic look with minimal upkeep.”
How We Picked
These products were selected based on a combination of durability, aesthetic appeal, ease of installation, maintenance requirements, and value. I prioritized materials that are popular with homeowners and widely available, ensuring a range of options from budget-friendly to premium. Each product was evaluated for its ability to withstand weather, resist pests, and maintain appearance over time. The ranking reflects a balance between overall performance and suitability for different types of buyers, from DIY enthusiasts to those seeking long-term investment. Ultimately, the goal was to highlight options that deliver reliable results in real-world conditions, not just features on paper.
| house siding | Material |
|---|---|
| CertainTeed Cedar Impressions | Polymer |
| Cedar Impressions Double 9 Inc | Injection molded durable polymer |
| GAF WeatherSide Emphasis Extra | Fiber cement |
| GAF WeatherSide Purity Straigh | Fiber cement |
| Polaris Homeside Select Double | — |
| Tando Beach House Shake Compos | Composite |
| CertainTeed Monogram Horizonta | Vinyl |
| Tando Beach House Shake Compos | Composite |
| GAF WeatherSide Profile 9 Fibe | Fiber cement |
| CertainTeed Board and Batten V | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing House Siding
Choosing house siding involves considering several factors beyond just appearance. Understanding your climate, maintenance willingness, budget, and aesthetic goals will help narrow down the best options. A good siding should offer durability and ease of upkeep, but also match your home’s style and your long-term plans. Here are key considerations to keep in mind before making a purchase:Material Durability and Climate Compatibility
Different siding materials perform better in certain climates. Fiber cement resists moisture, pests, and fire, making it ideal for humid or fire-prone areas. Vinyl is more susceptible to cracking in extreme cold but can be an affordable choice for moderate climates. Metal siding offers excellent longevity but may require more maintenance to prevent rust. Selecting a material that aligns with your local weather patterns helps ensure your investment lasts.
Maintenance Requirements
Some sidings, like fiber cement and composite options, demand minimal upkeep aside from occasional cleaning. Vinyl siding typically just needs periodic washing and is resistant to pests and rot. Natural wood or wood-look sidings may need regular sealing or staining to retain their appearance. Consider how much time and effort you’re willing to allocate to upkeep—more durable materials often justify higher initial costs with lower ongoing maintenance.
Aesthetic Appeal and Style
Your home’s exterior style influences your siding choice. Horizontal vinyl or fiber cement panels suit traditional homes, while vertical board-and-batten siding offers a more rustic or modern look. Shake and shingle styles provide texture and character but can be more expensive or complex to install. Strive for a balance between visual appeal and the architectural style of your house, ensuring the siding enhances curb appeal without overwhelming your budget.
Cost and Installation Complexity
Budget constraints often determine the material choice, but installation costs vary significantly. Vinyl siding is generally quick and straightforward to install, making it a favorite for DIYers. Fiber cement and composite shakes may require specialized skills or professional help, increasing upfront costs but offering better longevity. Be realistic about your skill level and available time, as improper installation can reduce lifespan and increase repair costs later.
Long-Term Value and Resale Potential
Investing in high-quality siding can boost your home’s resale value, especially in markets where curb appeal is paramount. Durable materials like fiber cement and premium vinyl tend to retain their appearance and structural integrity longer, potentially reducing repair costs over time. Conversely, cheaper, low-quality siding might save money initially but could lead to higher expenses and diminished appeal in the future. Think about your long-term plans before choosing a material.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I install fiber cement siding myself?
While some experienced DIYers can install fiber cement siding, it is generally recommended to hire professionals due to its weight, cutting requirements, and the need for specialized tools. Proper installation is crucial for maximizing durability and appearance. Mistakes such as improper sealing or fastening can lead to water infiltration or cracking over time. If you decide to attempt installation yourself, ensure you follow all safety guidelines and manufacturer’s instructions closely.
Is vinyl siding good for cold climates?
Vinyl siding can perform adequately in cold climates if it is rated for low temperatures, but it is more prone to cracking and warping when exposed to extreme cold. Choosing insulated vinyl options can improve performance and energy efficiency. However, in very harsh winter areas, alternatives like fiber cement or metal siding might offer better long-term durability and resistance to the elements. Consider your local climate and choose a product specifically designed to withstand it.
How often does siding need maintenance or replacement?
The maintenance frequency depends on the material. Vinyl siding typically requires periodic washing every few years. Fiber cement and composite options are among the most low-maintenance, often lasting 30 years or more with minimal upkeep. Natural wood or wood-look sidings may need sealing or staining every 3-5 years. Replacement timelines vary widely; high-quality materials tend to last longer, but all siding should be inspected regularly for damage or wear.
What is the most cost-effective siding for a tight budget?
Vinyl siding generally offers the best initial cost and ease of installation, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners. It provides decent durability and requires minimal maintenance, offering good value over its lifespan. However, cheaper vinyl options may fade or crack sooner, so investing in higher-quality vinyl can pay off in the long run. For just a bit more, composite or engineered wood sidings can provide a more attractive look and longer lifespan without a significant price jump.
Does siding increase my home’s energy efficiency?
Yes, certain sidings, especially insulated vinyl or fiber cement with insulation backing, can improve your home’s energy efficiency by reducing heat transfer. Properly installed siding acts as an additional barrier against temperature fluctuations, which can lower heating and cooling costs. However, the overall impact depends on the quality of installation and whether additional insulation is added behind the siding. In colder climates, investing in insulated siding can offer noticeable savings over time.
Conclusion
For homeowners seeking the best overall durability and appearance, the CertainTeed Cedar Impressions offers a realistic cedar look with low maintenance. Budget-conscious buyers will find the Polaris Vinyl Siding to be a practical choice, while those prioritizing longevity and fire resistance should consider the GAF Fiber-Cement Options. Beginners or DIY enthusiasts will benefit from the simplicity of vinyl siding, whereas premium buyers can opt for higher-end fiber cement or composite shakes. Ultimately, your choice depends on your climate, aesthetic preferences, and long-term investment goals—matching the right siding to your specific needs ensures lasting satisfaction.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
