For fans of murder mysteries, streaming offers a vast world of intrigue, suspense, and compelling storytelling. The best options combine engaging plots with high-quality production, but choosing the right service can be tricky. Mr. & Mrs. Murder: Series 1 stands out for its quirky humor, while Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Complete Collection offers a timeless classic feel. The main tradeoffs involve balancing binge-worthy content with genre variety and production quality. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown of the best options and what makes each unique.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The top streaming options excel in a mix of classic and modern murder mysteries, providing variety for different tastes.
- Collections like Miss Fisher’s series deliver long-term value, but may lack recent releases or updates.
- Quality and production value vary significantly, with premium picks offering cinematic experiences versus more casual options.
- Availability and regional licensing heavily influence which titles are accessible in your area.
- Price points differ, with some platforms bundling mystery series into larger streaming packages, impacting overall value.
| Mr. & Mrs. Murder: Series 1 |  | Best Lighthearted Crime Comedy | Number of episodes: 13 | Genre: Crime comedy | Format: Streaming | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| A Christmas Murder Mystery |  | Best Holiday-Themed Cozy Mystery | Genre: Holiday mystery | Format: Unknown | Theme: Christmas | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Complete Collection |  | Best Stylish Period Drama | Seasons: Multiple | Setting: 1920s Melbourne | Genre: Period mystery | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MS Fisher’s Modern Murder Mysteries Series 1 Blu-ray |  | Best Modern Spin on Classic Mysteries | Format: Blu-ray | Series: 1 | Country: Australia | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Garage Sale Mysteries: The Art of Murder |  | Best Cozy Mystery Novel | Format: Book | Genre: Cozy mystery | Series: Garage Sale Mysteries | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Complete Collection |  | Best Overall for Comprehensive Period Drama Enthusiasts | Format: Streaming / DVD / Blu-ray | Episodes: Full series included | Genre: Mystery, Drama, Period | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Murder, She W W Movie Collection |  | Best for Classic Mystery Fans Who Love Extended Stories | Format: Streaming / DVD | Number of Movies: 4 | Genre: Mystery, Drama | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Series 1 |  | Best for Newcomers to the Series or Those Preferring a Starting Point | Format: Streaming / DVD | Episodes: Series 1 | Genre: Mystery, Drama | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Series 2 |  | Best for Viewers Who Want More Depth and Character Development | Format: Streaming / DVD | Episodes: Series 2 | Genre: Mystery, Drama | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries |  | Best for General Audiences Interested in Vintage Detective Stories | Format: Streaming / DVD | Episodes: Single series | Genre: Mystery, Drama | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| murder mysteries streaming | Genre | Format | Language | Setting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mr. & Mrs. Murder: Series 1 | Crime comedy | Streaming | — | — |
| A Christmas Murder Mystery | Holiday mystery | Unknown | — | — |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Period mystery | — | — | 1920s Melbourne |
| MS Fisher’s Modern Murder Myst | — | Blu-ray | English | — |
| Garage Sale Mysteries: The Art | Cozy mystery | Book | — | — |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Mystery, Drama, Period | Streaming / DVD / Blu-ray | English | 1920s Melbourne |
| Murder | Mystery, Drama | Streaming / DVD | English | — |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Mystery, Drama | Streaming / DVD | English | 1920s Melbourne |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Mystery, Drama | Streaming / DVD | English | 1920s Melbourne |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Mystery, Drama | Streaming / DVD | English | 1920s Melbourne |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Mr. & Mrs. Murder: Series 1
This series stands out for its charming blend of humor and crime-solving, making it ideal for viewers who prefer their murder mysteries sprinkled with laughs. Compared with more serious crime dramas like Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Complete Collection, Mr. & Mrs. Murder offers a more comedic, less intense experience that’s perfect for casual viewing. The 13-episode format keeps it concise, but some might find the limited number of episodes and lighter tone less satisfying for deep crime analysis. Its engaging chemistry and witty banter make it a delightful pick for those seeking an entertaining escape rather than gritty realism.
Pros:- Entertaining mix of comedy and crime-solving
- Charming characters with good chemistry
- Includes 13 episodes of engaging storytelling
Cons:- May not appeal to those seeking serious crime dramas
- Limited episode count for viewers wanting more depth
Best for: Viewers who enjoy cozy, humorous mysteries with a romantic twist and lighthearted storytelling.
Not ideal for: Fans of darker, more serious crime dramas or viewers seeking complex, in-depth mysteries with detailed plot intricacies.
- Number of episodes:13
- Genre:Crime comedy
- Format:Streaming
Our verdict“This series is perfect for casual viewers who want a funny, charming mystery experience without the intensity of traditional crime dramas.”
A Christmas Murder Mystery
This festive mystery is ideal for holiday movie fans looking for a cozy whodunit with seasonal charm. Unlike Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries, which offers a more polished period setting, A Christmas Murder Mystery focuses solely on holiday cheer intertwined with suspense, making it perfect for seasonal binge-watching. However, the limited information on format and content might make it less appealing for viewers seeking a fully fleshed-out series or detailed technical info. Its simple, festive plot makes it a good choice for holiday movie nights but less so for those wanting a complex mystery experience.
Pros:- Engaging holiday-themed plot
- Great for cozy mystery fans
- Festive, lighthearted atmosphere
Cons:- No detailed description or series info
- Limited content for those who want more depth
Best for: Holiday lovers and fans of cozy mysteries seeking seasonal entertainment with a festive touch.
Not ideal for: Viewers looking for long-running series or detailed mystery plots, as this is a standalone holiday-themed story with limited information.
- Genre:Holiday mystery
- Format:Unknown
- Theme:Christmas
Our verdict“Choose this for a charming holiday mystery experience perfect for seasonal viewing, especially if you enjoy cozy, festive stories.”
Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Complete Collection
This complete series is the go-to for fans who appreciate elegant, well-crafted period mysteries set in 1920s Melbourne. Compared to Mr. & Mrs. Murder, which offers humor and lightness, Miss Fisher’s delivers a more glamorous, adventure-driven experience with strong performances, especially from Essie Davis. However, its historical setting and sometimes predictable plot may require viewers to have an interest in period dramas or be comfortable with a traditional mystery format. It’s a visually stunning series that appeals to those craving style and sophistication in their mysteries.
Pros:- Stylish and engaging period mystery series
- Strong lead performance by Essie Davis
- Set in a glamorous 1920s Melbourne
Cons:- May require familiarity with period dramas
- Some viewers might find the plot predictable
Best for: Fans of stylish, well-produced period dramas who enjoy character-driven stories with a touch of romance and adventure.
Not ideal for: Casual viewers or those seeking modern, fast-paced mysteries, as the series leans heavily into its historical aesthetics and slower pacing.
- Seasons:Multiple
- Setting:1920s Melbourne
- Genre:Period mystery
Our verdict“Ideal for viewers who appreciate elegant, visually rich mysteries set in an era of glamour and style.”
MS Fisher’s Modern Murder Mysteries Series 1 Blu-ray
This series offers a fresh take on the detective genre, placing Peregrine Fisher in 1960s Melbourne, which appeals to fans of stylish, character-driven mysteries. Compared with Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries, which is set in the 1920s, this series adapts the charm to a more modern aesthetic while maintaining a similar mix of humor and investigation. Its production quality and acting are solid, but its plot can sometimes feel predictable, especially for viewers familiar with detective series. It’s perfect for those seeking a modern yet nostalgic mystery series with strong female leads.
Pros:- Engaging mystery series with strong female leads
- Set in stylish 1960s Melbourne
- Good production quality and acting
Cons:- May appeal primarily to detective series fans
- Some plots may feel predictable
Best for: Fans of detective series who enjoy stylish settings and strong female protagonists in a slightly modernized era.
Not ideal for: Viewers who prefer authentic period atmospheres or complex, unpredictable plots, as the series occasionally leans on familiar tropes.
- Format:Blu-ray
- Series:1
- Country:Australia
- Language:English
Our verdict“A good pick for viewers who want a stylish, modern mystery with nostalgic flair and strong characters.”
Garage Sale Mysteries: The Art of Murder
This novel makes the list as a compelling entry in the cozy mystery genre, especially for those who enjoy stories centered on everyday settings like garage sales. Compared with Mr. & Mrs. Murder, which is a visual series, this book offers a more personal, immersive experience through its detailed storytelling. However, with limited information on its specific content, format, or length, it’s less ideal for readers who prefer multimedia or series-based mysteries. If you love solving puzzles in familiar, small-town settings, this series installment is worth considering.
Pros:- Engaging storyline
- Great for mystery enthusiasts
- Part of a popular series
Cons:- Limited information available
- No detailed specifications or format info
Best for: Mystery readers who enjoy cozy, character-driven stories set in familiar, everyday environments.
Not ideal for: Readers who seek visual mysteries or series with high production values, as this is a novel with no detailed technical info provided.
- Format:Book
- Genre:Cozy mystery
- Series:Garage Sale Mysteries
Our verdict“Ideal for cozy mystery fans who prefer immersive storytelling in a familiar setting and enjoy solving puzzles through reading.”
Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Complete Collection
This complete collection stands out for delivering the entire series of Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries, making it ideal for viewers who want an immersive experience. Compared with individual season sets like Series 1 or Series 2, this collection offers the full story arc, ensuring no plot point is missed. The show shines with its authentic 1920s Melbourne setting, stylish costumes, and a charismatic, modern female lead who redefines the detective genre. However, its appeal may be limited for those uninterested in period dramas or who find slow pacing challenging. It’s perfect for dedicated mystery fans craving a complete, character-driven experience, but not suited for casual viewers seeking quick-paced thrillers.
Pros:- Complete series offering comprehensive storytelling
- Authentic 1920s costumes and settings
- Features a charismatic, modern female protagonist
Cons:- May feel slow or uneventful for some viewers
- Limited appeal for those uninterested in period dramas
Best for: Fans of vintage detective stories who want a complete, visually stunning series with strong female leads.
Not ideal for: Viewers who dislike slow narratives or are not interested in period settings and historical drama.
- Format:Streaming / DVD / Blu-ray
- Episodes:Full series included
- Genre:Mystery, Drama, Period
- Setting:1920s Melbourne
- Main Character:Phryne Fisher
- Language:English
Our verdict“This collection suits dedicated mystery fans seeking a richly designed period drama with a strong lead, but may not satisfy those looking for fast-paced plots.”
Murder, She W W Movie Collection
This collection offers four full-length movies from Murder, She Wrote, making it ideal for longtime fans craving more Jessica Fletcher adventures. Compared to Series 1 or Series 2, which focus on episodic mysteries, these movies deliver longer, more complex plots with higher stakes. Angela Lansbury’s iconic portrayal of Jessica Fletcher makes these films engaging, especially for those nostalgic for the show’s golden era. The lack of bonus features and absence of recent releases could disappoint collectors or newer fans expecting extras or updated formats. It’s a strong pick for fans wanting full-length mysteries in one package, but not ideal for viewers seeking modern or high-definition content.
Pros:- Includes four full-length mystery movies
- Features Angela Lansbury’s iconic performance
- Ideal for nostalgic fans of the original series
Cons:- Limited to fans of the classic series
- No bonus content or special features
Best for: Fans of classic mystery series who want extended, movie-length stories featuring Jessica Fletcher.
Not ideal for: New viewers unfamiliar with Murder, She Wrote or those expecting recent releases with added content.
- Format:Streaming / DVD
- Number of Movies:4
- Genre:Mystery, Drama
- Main Actor:Angela Lansbury
- Language:English
- Release Date:Various (originally aired in the 1980s and 1990s)
Our verdict“This collection appeals most to fans seeking extended mysteries starring Jessica Fletcher but falls short for those wanting modern or feature-rich editions.”
Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Series 1
This first season of Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries introduces viewers to the glamorous Phryne Fisher and her charming Victorian Melbourne world. Compared to Series 2, which expands on character relationships and plot complexity, Series 1 offers a more straightforward entry point with self-contained mysteries. The show’s beautiful costumes and witty storytelling make it a standout, but its mature content—violence, nudity, and drug references—limits its audience. It’s perfect for newcomers wanting a stylish, character-driven mystery, but less suitable for viewers seeking family-friendly or lighter fare.
Pros:- Beautiful period costumes and authentic setting
- Engaging, witty storytelling with a charismatic lead
- Self-contained mysteries ideal for casual viewing
Cons:- Contains mature content that may not suit all audiences
- Some viewers might find the pacing slow or the content explicit
Best for: New viewers interested in stylish period mysteries with rich visual detail and character-driven plots.
Not ideal for: Younger audiences or those sensitive to mature content, as the series includes explicit scenes and adult themes.
- Format:Streaming / DVD
- Episodes:Series 1
- Genre:Mystery, Drama
- Setting:1920s Melbourne
- Main Character:Phryne Fisher
- Language:English
Our verdict“This season makes a strong entry point for fans of stylish mysteries who are comfortable with mature themes, but less so for sensitive viewers.”
Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries: Series 2
Following the success of Series 1, Series 2 deepens the narrative with richer character interactions and more intricate mysteries. Compared to the first season, it assumes viewers are familiar with the characters, which might slow newcomers but rewards returning fans with more nuance. The show’s signature 1920s style remains, and the ensemble cast continues to impress. However, those new to the series may find the pace sluggish or feel a lack of context initially. For dedicated fans, this season offers satisfying character growth, but it’s less ideal for casual viewers or those preferring standalone episodes.
Pros:- Deeper character development and more complex plots
- Stylish costumes and authentic 1920s setting
- Strong ensemble cast
Cons:- May require familiarity with Series 1
- Some viewers might find the slow pacing
Best for: Fans of the series seeking more in-depth storytelling and character development in a period setting.
Not ideal for: First-time viewers or those who prefer quick, self-contained mysteries without prior series context.
- Format:Streaming / DVD
- Episodes:Series 2
- Genre:Mystery, Drama
- Setting:1920s Melbourne
- Main Character:Phryne Fisher
- Language:English
Our verdict“This season appeals most to committed fans wanting richer stories, but may challenge newcomers unfamiliar with earlier episodes.”
Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries
This series delivers the charm and intrigue of 1920s Melbourne through the charismatic Phryne Fisher, combining mystery, drama, and period flair. While the core appeal overlaps with Series 1 and Series 2, this entry offers a condensed glimpse of the show’s essence for viewers who prefer a straightforward introduction. Its limited detailed information and lack of extras make it less appealing for collectors or those seeking added content. Nonetheless, it provides a solid, entertaining period mystery experience for fans of vintage detective stories who don’t need the full series or extensive special features.
Pros:- Entertaining period drama with strong female lead
- Engaging mysteries with vintage flair
- Appeals to fans of classic detective stories
Cons:- Limited detailed specs and features
- Less suitable for viewers seeking in-depth series or extras
Best for: Casual viewers or newcomers looking for a standalone, engaging period mystery with period charm.
Not ideal for: Dedicated fans wanting comprehensive collections or those seeking detailed bonus content.
- Format:Streaming / DVD
- Episodes:Single series
- Genre:Mystery, Drama
- Setting:1920s Melbourne
- Main Character:Phryne Fisher
- Language:English
Our verdict“This series offers an entertaining introduction to Phryne Fisher’s world, ideal for casual viewers or those new to the series.”
How We Picked
I evaluated each streaming option based on content quality, genre variety, accessibility, and user experience. Preference was given to platforms offering full seasons or collections, high-definition streaming, and internationally available titles. Consideration was also given to price, subscription flexibility, and how well each service caters to mystery enthusiasts. Rankings reflect a balance of these factors, prioritizing options that deliver consistent, high-quality murder mystery content for a broad audience.| murder mysteries streaming | Genre | Format |
|---|---|---|
| Mr. & Mrs. Murder: Series 1 | Crime comedy | Streaming |
| A Christmas Murder Mystery | Holiday mystery | Unknown |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Period mystery | — |
| MS Fisher’s Modern Murder Myst | — | Blu-ray |
| Garage Sale Mysteries: The Art | Cozy mystery | Book |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Mystery, Drama, Period | Streaming / DVD / Blu-ray |
| Murder | Mystery, Drama | Streaming / DVD |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Mystery, Drama | Streaming / DVD |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Mystery, Drama | Streaming / DVD |
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Mystery, Drama | Streaming / DVD |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Murder Mysteries Streaming
Choosing the right murder mysteries streaming service depends on several key factors. Beyond just the titles available, consider how easy it is to access content, the quality of the streaming experience, and whether the platform offers a good balance of classic and contemporary series. Being aware of potential pitfalls, like limited regional access or excessive costs for small libraries, can help you make a smarter choice. The following factors will guide you through making an informed decision.Content Library and Variety
Look for a platform that offers a broad selection of murder mysteries, including both classic series and newer releases. A diverse library ensures you won’t run out of options quickly, and it allows you to explore different styles and eras of storytelling. Beware of services with limited titles or those heavily skewed toward a specific type of mystery, which could narrow your enjoyment over time.
Streaming Quality and User Experience
High-definition streaming and a smooth, intuitive interface make a significant difference in long viewing sessions. Check whether the service supports multiple devices, offline viewing, and has reliable playback without buffering. A cluttered or confusing interface can diminish your experience, especially when binge-watching complex mysteries with lots of details.
Availability and Regional Access
Some streaming platforms have limited regional licensing, restricting access to certain series based on your location. Verify the availability of your favorite titles before subscribing, particularly if you’re interested in specific collections like Miss Fisher’s series. Consider services that offer global access or multiple regional options if you travel or live outside major markets.
Pricing and Subscription Models
Compare subscription costs, including whether there are tiered plans or free trials. Beware of platforms that require multiple add-ons or expensive bundles for access to the full library. Sometimes, investing in a higher-tier service offers better value in terms of content volume and quality, especially if you’re a dedicated mystery fan.
Additional Features and Special Content
Look for extras like behind-the-scenes footage, episode guides, or exclusive interviews, which can enrich your viewing experience. Some platforms also curate themed collections or recommend titles based on your viewing history, helping you discover new favorites. Weigh these perks against subscription costs to determine if they add enough value for your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I stream murder mysteries on multiple devices simultaneously?
Most streaming services allow multiple devices under a single subscription, but the number of simultaneous streams varies. Check the platform’s plan details—premium tiers often support more concurrent streams, which is useful if multiple people in your household enjoy mystery series. Ensuring this feature is available can prevent conflicts during peak viewing times.
Are there free options for streaming murder mysteries?
Some platforms offer free tiers with limited content or ad-supported access, but these usually lack the full range of series, collections, or HD quality. For a comprehensive experience with no interruptions, a paid subscription generally delivers better value. If you’re on a tight budget, look for trial periods or bundle deals that let you explore the content before committing.
How important is streaming quality for murder mysteries?
Streaming quality significantly impacts the enjoyment of murder mysteries, especially those with cinematic visuals or intricate plot details. A crisp, high-definition picture allows you to catch subtle clues and appreciate the setting, which are often vital in solving the mystery. Poor quality or buffering can detract from immersion and overall satisfaction.
Should I prioritize older series or recent releases?
This depends on your preferences. Classic series like Miss Fisher’s provide timeless charm and often have large collections, but newer mysteries tend to have higher production values and current storytelling styles. Balancing both can give you a well-rounded viewing experience, but if you prefer nostalgia, focus on platforms with extensive older titles.
What should I do if my favorite series isn’t available in my region?
If a title isn’t accessible locally, consider using a VPN to access content from other regions—though be aware of the legal implications and platform policies. Alternatively, look for services that offer broader international licensing or check if the series is available through other streaming platforms or physical media. Being flexible can help you enjoy a wider range of mysteries without restrictions.
