AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

TL;DR

Musician Samantha Shokin’s YouTube recording of the Bulgarian folk song “Bre Petrunko” was removed after Media Nov Records filed a copyright complaint. The company withdrew its request after questions from Shokin and 404 Media, and YouTube restored the video; Media Nov said it was not surrendering its position in a wider rights dispute.

YouTube restored musician Samantha Shokin’s recording of the Bulgarian folk song “Bre Petrunko” after Media Nov Records withdrew a copyright complaint that had taken the video down. The dispute concerns a recording Shokin made during the pandemic, years before the company was founded, according to corporate records cited by 404 Media.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get audio and creator gear delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Shokin recorded a 50-second version of “Bre Petrunko” during the pandemic, first uploading it to SoundCloud and later to YouTube. The video eventually reached about 125,000 views. Last summer, she noticed more comments and found that DJs had sampled her voice in dozens of tracks. She later learned the samples had been distributed in a Loopmasters pack called “Folk Legends.” Loopmasters apologized, said it had not known what had happened and arranged royalties, according to the report.

In October, Shokin’s original YouTube video disappeared following a complaint from Media Nov Records. She submitted two counter-notifications arguing that the video should remain available or should not be demonetized, but they failed. She also tried to contact the company without receiving a response at the time, she told 404 Media. Media Nov later said its earlier messages from Shokin and Loopmasters had gone to its spam folder.

After 404 Media contacted the company, Media Nov said it would investigate and correct any error. It then asked Shokin for original audio files, evidence of the recording and publication dates, and other documentation of ownership. The company withdrew its removal request minutes after asking for that material. YouTube confirmed to 404 Media that it restored the video because the claimant had withdrawn the complaint.

At a glance
reportWhen: The video was removed in October and re…
The developmentYouTube restored Samantha Shokin’s recording after Media Nov Records withdrew a copyright complaint that had removed the video.

How a Claim Can Remove a Recording

The case shows how a copyright complaint can make a musician’s own recording unavailable while the claim is being handled. Shokin’s video was restored after the claimant withdrew its request, but her two counter-notifications had not succeeded before that withdrawal. The report does not explain YouTube’s review process in detail, so the case alone cannot establish how similar disputes are resolved across the platform.

It also highlights the difficulty of separating rights in a song from rights in a particular performance or recording. “Bre Petrunko” is a traditional folk song, while Shokin’s voice and specific recording are separate elements. A dispute over one does not, by itself, establish ownership of the other. The distinction matters to musicians whose recordings are sampled, distributed or flagged by rights-management systems.

Products Worth Considering

Apple MacBook Air 15-inch Laptop with M5 Chip, 24GB Memory, 1TB SSD, Midnight

Apple MacBook Air 15-inch Laptop with M5 Chip, 24GB Memory, 1TB SSD, Midnight

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

From Folk Song to Rights Dispute

Shokin’s recording was made roughly five years before the copyright complaint, according to the report. The folk song has a separate history: Bulgarian composer Philip Koutev popularized an arrangement in 1963. Media Nov told Shokin that rights to Koutev’s composition and arrangement should be distinguished from rights in an individual sound recording, and said it held certain rights relating to the musical content.

404 Media described Media Nov as a distribution company that helps artists place tracks on digital services, while noting that its website also promotes rights management, automated takedowns, YouTube Content ID management and AI-powered content recognition. The company told the outlet it operates 500 channels. 404 Media reported that corporate records placed its founding last year, although the company website claimed roots in 1996. The source report does not establish how those claims about the company’s history are reconciled.

““The first thing that comes to mind is, ‘Oh my god, someone stole my voice and didn’t credit me.’””

— Samantha Shokin, speaking to 404 Media

Ownership Claims Still Unresolved

The video’s restoration does not resolve the underlying copyright dispute. Media Nov said it was not surrendering its position and intended to pursue legal proceedings, but the report does not establish whether it filed a case or what rights it claims over Shokin’s recording. The company also did not tell 404 Media which work in its catalog had triggered the complaint.

It remains unclear what evidence Media Nov relied on when it filed the removal request, how the company’s claimed rights relate to Shokin’s particular voice recording, and what outcome any further dispute might produce. The report also does not identify the year of the October takedown or the restoration.

Possible Legal Steps Ahead

Media Nov said it intended to pursue legal proceedings over the underlying copyright dispute, but no filing or timetable was reported. The company’s withdrawal of the YouTube request allowed the video to return; it did not amount to a stated concession on ownership.

Any further development would depend on whether Media Nov takes legal action and what evidence each side presents about the song, arrangement and recording. For now, Shokin’s video is back on YouTube, while the ownership claims described in the report remain unresolved.

Key Questions

Why was Samantha Shokin’s YouTube video removed?

Media Nov Records filed a copyright complaint against the video. The report does not identify which specific work or rights the company relied on when making the claim.

Has YouTube restored the recording?

Yes. YouTube told 404 Media it restored the video after Media Nov withdrew its removal request.

Does the restoration settle who owns the rights?

No. Media Nov said it was not surrendering its rights position and intended to pursue legal proceedings. The report does not establish the outcome of any further action.

What is the difference between the folk song and Shokin’s recording?

The song and Koutev’s arrangement are distinct from Shokin’s individual voice performance and sound recording. Media Nov cited that distinction in its email, but the specific rights it claims in this case remain unclear.

Source: techspot.com

You May Also Like

Instagram’s Worldwide AI Age Checks Raise Questions About Accuracy

Meta is expanding Instagram’s AI system for identifying suspected teen users globally, but has not disclosed its error rate or appeal process.

Use Live Content To Introduce Your Paid Community

An IdeaNavigator AI proposal would show selected live community activity on creator sales pages, with a 20-page test to measure conversions.

ByteDance GenAI R&D Head’s Exit Follows Two Other Core Member Departures

A 36Kr headline reports that ByteDance’s GenAI R&D head is leaving for embodied intelligence, alongside three core-member departures in four months.