When it comes to selecting a toilet, a combination of performance, comfort, and value drives the decision. The Gerber Maxwell Crest stands out as the best overall for its reliable flush and sleek design, while the TOTO Drake offers top-tier flushing power for those prioritizing efficiency. For those on a budget, the DeerValley ADA Compliant provides solid performance at a sensible price. The main tradeoffs often involve balancing features like comfort height, water efficiency, and ease of installation. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown of these options to find the best fit for your bathroom.
Get audio and creator gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The top-ranked models combine reliable flushing mechanisms with durable build quality.
- Comfort height and ADA compliance are key factors for accessibility-focused buyers.
- Dual-flush options provide significant water savings but may come with higher upfront costs.
- Compact and skirted designs are ideal for modern bathrooms but can be more difficult to install or repair.
- Price range varies widely, with premium models offering advanced features and entry-level options focusing on affordability.
| toilet | Flush Rate | Color |
|---|---|---|
| Gerber Maxwell Crest Elongated | 1.28 gpf | White |
| Gerber Viper Force Elongated T | 1.28 gpf | White |
| DeerValley Two-Piece ADA Compl | — | White |
| Gerber Maxwell Select Elongate | — | White |
| TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated | 1.6 GPF | Cotton White |
| DeerValley Compact One Piece T | 1.1/1.6 GPF | — |
| HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet | — | — |
| Casta Diva One Piece Elongated | 1.0 GPF for liquids, 1.28 GPF for solids | — |
| Casta Diva Elongated One Piece | 1.1 GPF / 1.6 GPF | — |
| Casta Diva Elongated One Piece | — | — |
| Simple Project 21 Inch Elongat | 1.28 GPF | White |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Gerber Maxwell Crest Elongated Two-Piece Toilet, Soft-Close Seat, White
This Gerber Maxwell Crest stands out as the best overall choice because it balances water efficiency with reliable performance. Its 1.28 gpf flush effectively clears the bowl, comparable to other water-saving options like the Gerber Viper Force, but with a more traditional two-piece design that many find easier to maintain. The soft-close seat adds convenience, and its proven flush system minimizes clogs, making it suitable for busy households. The main tradeoff is the limited color options, which could be a drawback for those seeking a customized look. Overall, it delivers solid performance for everyday use without the extra cost of premium models.
Pros:- Efficient 1.28 gpf flush saves water without sacrificing performance
- Soft-close seat prevents noise and accidental slamming
- Reliable flush system reduces chances of clogging
Cons:- Limited color options restrict aesthetic customization
- No mention of ease of installation or detailed warranty info
Best for: Families seeking a reliable, water-efficient toilet with quiet operation and straightforward maintenance.
Not ideal for: Homeowners wanting a wider range of color choices or a one-piece design for seamless cleaning.
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Color:White
- Flush Rate:1.28 gpf
- Seat:Elongated, soft-close
Our verdict“This toilet offers a dependable, water-saving solution suited for those valuing performance and quiet operation.”
Gerber Viper Force Elongated Two-Piece Toilet, Soft-Close Seat, White
The Gerber Viper Force excels for its quick, tool-free installation, making it a top pick for DIYers or those replacing an existing toilet without professional help. It features a high-efficiency 1.28 gpf flush that matches the performance of the Maxwell Crest but with the added convenience of an included installation kit. Its durable design and soft-close seat enhance long-term usability. Compared to the DeerValley ADA, which offers a higher height for comfort, the Viper Force prioritizes ease of setup. However, it only comes in white and lacks detailed warranty info, which could be a concern for long-term peace of mind.
Pros:- Powerful, water-saving 1.28 gpf flush
- Quick, tool-free installation with included hardware
- Soft-close seat for quiet, convenient use
- Trusted durability from a reputable brand
Cons:- Limited color choices (only white)
- Lack of detailed warranty information
Best for: Homeowners or renters looking for a reliable, water-efficient toilet that’s quick to install and maintain.
Not ideal for: Those seeking a toilet with a wide range of color options or specific ADA height features.
- Brand:Gerber
- Model Number:GRS48352
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Color:White
- Flush Rate:1.28 gpf
- Included Components:Bowl, Installation hardware, Soft-close seat, Tank, Wax ring
Our verdict“This model makes the most sense for those prioritizing easy installation and dependable performance with minimal fuss.”
DeerValley Two-Piece ADA Compliant Elongated Toilet with Power Flush and Soft-Close Seat
The DeerValley ADA Compliant offers an elevated 17 13/16-inch height, making it ideal for those with mobility challenges or anyone valuing comfort. Its powerful, water-efficient flush system ensures effective clearing, comparable to the Viper Force but with added ergonomic benefits. The quiet-close elongated seat enhances convenience, and its sleek design fits well in modern bathrooms. The main tradeoff is the two-piece construction, which can be more challenging to install and clean than one-piece models. Additionally, its one-year warranty is shorter than some premium options, but its focus on accessibility makes it stand out for specific user needs.
Pros:- Elevated ADA height offers easy sitting and standing
- Powerful, water-efficient flush system
- Quiet-close elongated seat for convenience
- Modern, sleek appearance
Cons:- Two-piece design may be harder to install and clean
- Limited warranty period of one year
Best for: Individuals with mobility issues or seniors who prefer ADA height for ease of use.
Not ideal for: Those seeking a simple, lower-height toilet for small bathrooms or quick installation.
- Rough-in:12 inches
- Water Flow Rate:1.28 GPF
- Height:17 13/16 inches
- Type:Two-piece
- Bowl Shape:Elongated
- Color:White
Our verdict“This toilet is best suited for those prioritizing comfort and accessibility over installation simplicity.”
Gerber Maxwell Select Elongated Two-Piece Dual-Flush Toilet, White
The Gerber Maxwell Select offers a versatile dual-flush system, allowing users to choose between 1.28 and 1.0 gpf, making it ideal for high-traffic bathrooms aiming for water conservation. Its canister flush valve provides a strong, clog-resistant flush, comparable to the single-flush models but with added flexibility in water use. The soft-close seat enhances comfort and quiet operation, but the dual-flush mechanism may require professional installation for optimal performance. Its elongated shape might not suit smaller bathrooms, and the absence of color options limits customization. This model’s primary appeal lies in its efficiency and durability for demanding environments.
Pros:- Dual-flush system saves water with two options
- Strong, clog-resistant flush mechanism
- Soft-close seat prevents noise
- Canister flush valve enhances durability
Cons:- May require professional installation for best results
- Elongated seat may not fit compact spaces
Best for: Commercial or busy household bathrooms needing a reliable, water-efficient toilet for frequent use.
Not ideal for: Small bathrooms where space is limited or users prefer a simple single-flush system.
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Color:White
- Flush options:Dual-flush 1.28/1.0 gpf
- Seat:Soft-close elongated
Our verdict“This dual-flush toilet balances high efficiency and durability, ideal for high-use settings where water savings matter most.”
TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated 1.6 GPF Universal Height Toilet with CEFIONTECT – Cotton White
The TOTO Drake distinguishes itself with its powerful Tornado flush system and CEFIONTECT glaze, which significantly reduces waste buildup and simplifies cleaning. Its universal height incorporates ADA compliance, providing extra comfort for many users, unlike the lower models like the Maxwell Crest. While it uses 1.6 GPF, which is slightly less water-efficient than the 1.28 gpf options, its superior cleaning performance and stylish design justify the tradeoff for many. Installation needs extra parts like a wax ring and bolts, which might add to setup time. Overall, this toilet offers a sleek look and high performance for those willing to invest in long-term cleanliness and comfort.
Pros:- Powerful Tornado flush ensures thorough cleaning
- CEFIONTECT glaze minimizes waste buildup
- Universal height provides enhanced comfort and ADA compliance
- Modern, stylish appearance
Cons:- Requires additional parts for installation
- Uses 1.6 GPF, slightly less water-efficient than some models
Best for: Design-conscious buyers seeking a stylish, easy-to-maintain toilet with ADA comfort features.
Not ideal for: Environmentally focused users seeking the lowest possible water usage or those with limited installation resources.
- Flush Rate:1.6 GPF
- Trap Seal:2-1/8″
- Minimum Water Pressure:8 psi
- Height:Universal Height
- Bowl Shape:Elongated
- Color:Cotton White
- Rough-in Size:12 inches
Our verdict“This model suits those prioritizing style, cleaning ease, and ADA comfort over maximum water savings.”
DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet with Soft-Close Seat, Dual Flush, 12″ Rough-In, Skirted Design
This compact one-piece toilet scores highly for small bathrooms where space is tight, thanks to its streamlined, skirted bowl that simplifies cleaning and reduces crevices. Compared to larger models like the HOROW T0338W, it sacrifices some versatility in size but excels at fitting into tight spots without sacrificing flushing power, thanks to dual flush technology. The soft-close seat adds a quiet touch, ideal for shared spaces. A key tradeoff is that installation might require a professional, especially if plumbing is unconventional. This makes it a smart choice for those prioritizing space and water efficiency but not suited for larger, more flexible bathroom layouts.
Pros:- Space-saving design perfect for small bathrooms
- Water-efficient dual flush system reduces water bills
- Easy-to-clean skirted bowl minimizes hidden dirt
- Quiet soft-close seat enhances comfort
Cons:- May require professional installation due to plumbing setup
- Limited to small bathroom spaces, not suitable for larger rooms
Best for: Homeowners with small bathrooms needing a space-saving and water-efficient toilet.
Not ideal for: Households with larger bathrooms or those seeking a high-capacity, more customizable fixture.
- Dimensions:24½”L×13⅜”W×28⅜”H
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.1/1.6 GPF
- Weight Capacity:250 lbs
Our verdict“This toilet is ideal for small bathroom upgrades where space and water savings are priorities.”
HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet with ADA Chair Height 17.3″ Dual Flush
The HOROW T0338W stands out for its ADA-compliant 17.3-inch seat height, making it easier for seniors and those with mobility challenges to sit and stand comfortably. Unlike the compact DeerValley, it offers a more ergonomic height while maintaining a compact footprint suitable for small bathrooms. Its dual flush system ensures water savings, but installation can be tricky if your rough-in isn’t exactly 10 or 12 inches, possibly requiring adjustments. This model is better suited for users prioritizing accessibility without needing a full remodeling, though it’s less ideal if you prefer ultra-low-profile toilets.
Pros:- Comfortable ADA chair height for easier use
- Water-efficient dual flush system
- Compact footprint fits small bathrooms
- Includes soft-close seat for quiet operation
Cons:- Installation may need rough-in adjustments
- Limited to 10 or 12-inch rough-in sizes
Best for: Elderly or mobility-impaired users needing a comfortable, accessible toilet in a small bathroom.
Not ideal for: Homeowners with standard-height toilets or those with irregular rough-in dimensions who might face installation challenges.
- Dimensions:26.6″D x 15″W x 26″H
- Seat Height:17.3″
- Flush Options:1.1/1.6 GPF
- Trapway:2″ fully-glazed siphon
Our verdict“This toilet offers accessible comfort in small spaces, making it ideal for mobility-challenged users with tight bathroom layouts.”
Casta Diva One Piece Elongated Toilet with 17.5″ ADA Height Comfort Seat
The Casta Diva 17.5″ ADA height toilet combines a sleek, skirted design with a powerful siphon jet flush, making it a top choice for those who want both style and function. Compared to the HOROW model, it offers a more modern look with a seamless surface that simplifies cleaning. Its dual-flush system balances water efficiency with performance, but installation can be slightly more involved if plumbing isn’t ready for a skirted unit. It’s suited for homeowners upgrading their bathrooms who value aesthetics without sacrificing performance, but limited color options might be a drawback for some.
Pros:- Sleek, seamless design for easy cleaning
- Powerful siphon jet flush with high performance score
- Dual-flush water-saving feature
- Comfortable 17.5-inch ADA height
Cons:- Installation may need plumbing adjustments
- Limited color options (white only)
Best for: Homeowners seeking a modern, efficient toilet with easy cleaning in a standard bathroom.
Not ideal for: Users requiring a non-ADA height or those with limited plumbing flexibility, as installation may be complex.
- Height:26.57 inches
- Depth:25.39 inches
- Width:14.56 inches
- Seat Height:17.5 inches
- Flush Rate:1.0 GPF for liquids, 1.28 GPF for solids
- Material:Ceramic
Our verdict“This model is perfect for those wanting a stylish, high-performance toilet that’s easy to maintain and ADA compliant.”
Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet with 17-Inch Comfort Chair Height Seat
The Casta Diva 17-inch comfort height toilet combines a seamless, modern design with reliable performance, making it an excellent upgrade for most bathrooms. Its siphon jet flush system earns a high performance score, comparable to premium models like the TOTO Drake. The dual-flush feature helps conserve water, and the soft-close lid enhances quiet operation. Installation is straightforward for those familiar with standard plumbing, but some may find the skirted design a slight challenge. It’s ideal for homeowners seeking a balance of comfort, style, and efficiency, though color choices are limited to white.
Pros:- Modern, seamless design for easy cleaning
- Powerful siphon jet flush with high score
- Dual-flush water-saving technology
- Comfortable 17-inch seat height
Cons:- Installation may require plumbing knowledge
- Limited color options (white only)
Best for: Homeowners upgrading their bathroom with a focus on comfort, style, and efficiency.
Not ideal for: Those with non-standard rough-in sizes or seeking a more colorful aesthetic, as options are limited.
- Rough-in Size:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.1 GPF / 1.6 GPF
- Bowl Shape:Elongated
- Seat Height:17 inches
- Material:Porcelain
- Warranty:1-year limited
Our verdict“This toilet is well-suited for those seeking a stylish, efficient upgrade with comfort and ease of maintenance in mind.”
Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet with 17.2″ ADA Comfort Height Seat
The Casta Diva 17.2″ ADA toilet features an air-pressure-assisted flush system that delivers powerful, efficient flushing without electricity, making it ideal for areas with low water pressure. Its sleek, one-piece design with a soft-close seat combines modern aesthetics with functionality, similar to the DeerValley compact model but with added accessibility benefits. While it uses only 1.0 GPF—meeting EPA standards—it’s heavier and bulkier, which could complicate installation or cleaning in tight spaces. This pick makes the most sense for those needing a high-efficiency, accessible toilet that operates reliably in low-pressure environments, but less so for users prioritizing lightweight fixtures or extensive color options.
Pros:- Powerful, efficient flush suitable for low-pressure areas
- ADA-compliant comfort height for easy use
- Sleek design with soft-close seat
- Water-saving 1.0 GPF performance
Cons:- Requires additional components for full installation
- Heavier and bulkier than standard toilets
- Limited color choices
Best for: Residents in low-pressure water areas or those needing a low-energy, ADA-compliant toilet with strong flushing power.
Not ideal for: Users who prefer lightweight, standard-height toilets or need multiple color options, as this model is bulkier and limited in palette.
- Material:Vitreous china
- Flush System:Air-pressure assisted, siphon jet
- Water Usage:1.0 GPF
- Seat Height:17.2 inches
- Bowl Shape:Elongated
- Rough-in Size:12 inches
Our verdict“This toilet offers a powerful, efficient flush ideal for low-pressure areas and accessibility needs, though its weight and size may pose installation challenges.”
Simple Project 21 Inch Elongated Extra Tall Toilet for Seniors
This model stands out for its elevated 21-inch height, making it an excellent choice for seniors, tall adults, or anyone with mobility challenges. Compared with standard height toilets like the TOTO Drake, the extra height reduces strain on knees and hips, providing a more comfortable experience. Its elongated bowl offers improved sitting comfort, but may not fit well in small bathrooms where space is tight. The water-efficient 1.28 GPF flush balances performance with conservation, though it might require a stronger flush for very heavy use. The soft-close seat enhances peace and quiet, especially appreciated in shared spaces, while the durable ceramic ensures longevity. Unlike some ADA-compliant options like the DeerValley ADA Toilet, this model prioritizes comfort with its higher seat, but does require a 12-inch rough-in, which isn’t compatible with all bathrooms. Overall, this pick is ideal for those prioritizing ease of use and comfort over tight space constraints.
Pros:- Elevated height reduces knee and hip strain, easing mobility issues
- Water-efficient 1.28 GPF flush helps conserve water without sacrificing performance
- Soft-close seat eliminates slamming noise for quiet operation
- Durable ceramic construction ensures long-term use
Cons:- May require a footstool for users under 5’4″ to achieve optimal support
- Requires a 12-inch rough-in, limiting compatibility with some bathrooms
- Elongated bowl may not fit in very small or compact spaces
Best for: Seniors or tall adults seeking a comfortable, easy-to-use toilet with water savings.
Not ideal for: Small bathrooms or homes with 10-inch rough-in plumbing, where the 12-inch rough-in might not fit or the space is too limited.
- Height:21 inches
- Rough-in:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Material:High-density ceramic
- Installation Type:Two-piece
- Color:White
Our verdict“This toilet is best suited for seniors and taller individuals prioritizing comfort and ease of use in accessible bathrooms.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these toilets based on several criteria that matter most to buyers: flushing performance, water efficiency, ease of installation, durability, and comfort. I also considered user reviews and brand reputation to ensure longevity and customer satisfaction. The ranking reflects a balance between value and features, prioritizing models that deliver consistent performance without unnecessary complexity. Products were selected to cover a range of needs, from basic functionality to high-end luxury, ensuring there is a top choice for different types of buyers.Factors to Consider When Choosing Toilets
Choosing the right toilet involves more than just price; understanding key features can help you avoid common pitfalls and pick the best model for your bathroom. Consider your space constraints, household needs, and budget when evaluating options. The following factors will guide you through the most important considerations to make an informed decision that lasts for years.Flushing System and Performance
The core function of a toilet is its flushing ability. Look for models with proven flushing mechanisms, such as gravity-fed or pressure-assisted systems, which influence how well waste is cleared and how often blockages occur. High-performance flushes reduce the need for multiple flushes, saving water and maintenance costs in the long run. Be cautious with cheaper models that may clog easily or require frequent repairs, even if they seem affordable initially.
Water Efficiency and Flush Options
Water-saving features like dual-flush systems can significantly reduce your household water bills. These options let you choose between a light flush for liquid waste and a full flush for solids, conserving water without sacrificing performance. However, some dual-flush models may have a more complex mechanism that could be prone to issues over time. Balance your desire for efficiency with reliability by selecting models with a good track record for durability.
Comfort and Accessibility Features
Comfort height or ADA-compliant models are designed for easier use by seniors, people with mobility issues, or those who simply prefer a higher seat. While these models tend to be more expensive, they can improve bathroom usability dramatically. Keep in mind that taller toilets might not fit well in bathrooms with limited space, so measuring carefully is essential before purchasing. Comfort features often come with tradeoffs in installation complexity or cleaning accessibility.
Design and Installation Considerations
Modern toilets come in various styles, including one-piece and two-piece designs, each with benefits and drawbacks. One-piece toilets offer a sleek look and easier cleaning, but tend to be more expensive and heavier. Two-piece models are generally more affordable and easier to repair, but may require more effort to keep clean. Additionally, consider your bathroom’s rough-in size and whether a skirted or traditional design better suits your aesthetic and maintenance preferences.
Price and Long-Term Value
While budget options may seem attractive, they often come with compromises in performance or durability. Investing a bit more upfront can lead to savings over time through fewer repairs and better water efficiency. Conversely, premium models with advanced features like automatic flushing or heated seats tend to serve specific needs and may not be necessary for everyone. Assess your priorities carefully to find the best mix of cost and long-term benefits.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if a toilet will fit in my bathroom?
Measuring your existing space is essential before purchasing a toilet. Focus on the rough-in measurement, which is the distance from the wall behind the toilet to the center of the drain pipe. Most standard toilets have a 12-inch rough-in, but some models are available with 10 or 14 inches. Confirm your space and choose a model that matches these dimensions to ensure a proper fit and avoid costly modifications later.
Are dual-flush toilets worth the extra cost?
Dual-flush toilets can offer significant water savings over traditional models, especially in homes with high water bills or eco-conscious buyers. While they may have a higher upfront price, the reduced water consumption can lead to noticeable savings over time. However, some dual-flush models might have more complex mechanisms that could require maintenance or repairs, so selecting a reliable brand is key to maximizing their benefits.
What is the difference between one-piece and two-piece toilets?
One-piece toilets integrate the tank and bowl into a single unit, creating a smooth, easier-to-clean surface and a modern look. They tend to be more expensive and heavier to install. Two-piece toilets feature a separate tank and bowl, making them more affordable and easier to transport and repair. Your choice depends on your aesthetic preference, budget, and maintenance willingness—one-piece models generally require less cleaning but cost more upfront.
How important is the height of the toilet seat?
Seat height influences comfort, especially for taller adults or those with mobility issues. Standard toilets generally have a seat height of around 15 inches, while comfort or ADA-height models range from 17 to 19 inches. Higher seats reduce strain during sitting and standing, but might not fit well in smaller bathrooms. It’s worth considering your household’s specific needs and measuring the space before choosing a taller model.
Should I prioritize water efficiency over flushing power?
Balancing water efficiency with flushing power is key. Modern low-flow toilets can deliver excellent performance with significantly less water, but some cheaper models may struggle with waste removal. Choosing a high-quality, efficient flush system ensures you don’t sacrifice performance for savings. If you have a high-volume household or particular waste management needs, prioritize models that excel in flushing while still conserving water.
Conclusion
For most households, the Gerber Maxwell Crest offers an excellent combination of reliability, style, and value, making it the best overall choice. Buyers on a budget will appreciate the DeerValley ADA Compliant model for its solid features at a lower price. Those seeking luxury or advanced features should consider the TOTO Drake or premium models with smart functions. For seniors or those with mobility concerns, comfort height or ADA-compliant toilets provide the best experience. Ultimately, your choice should reflect your space, needs, and budget, ensuring a durable and comfortable bathroom upgrade.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
