🔍 Read the full analysis: Can You Refuse AI At Work Without Losing Legal Protection? on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get audio and creator gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
TL;DR
The University of Kentucky approved research administrator David Durman’s request to be excused from personally using AI tools, based on his sincerely held Humanist beliefs. The decision is an individual workplace accommodation, not a court ruling; other workers’ requests will depend on their beliefs, job duties and the burden on their employer.
The University of Kentucky approved research administrator David Durman’s request to be excused from personally using artificial intelligence tools at work, citing his sincerely held Humanist beliefs. The September 25 decision is an individual accommodation, not a court ruling, and does not establish a blanket right for employees to refuse AI.
Durman helps researchers apply for grants. After AI tools were promoted for workplace tasks, he asked the university’s Office of Equal Opportunity to excuse him from personally using AI and large language models, including automated transcription, note-taking and decision-making systems. His request covered tools already in use as well as ones adopted later. He offered to take and share meeting notes himself, according to his letter published by the American Humanist Association.
The timeline reported by the AHA and Religion News Service begins with a July 31 department meeting where Microsoft Teams Copilot was promoted for meeting notes. Durman sent his request on August 24, met with university officials and AHA staff attorney Alexandria Huiskens in mid-September, and received approval on September 25. The AHA said the office found the accommodation would impose no undue burden on his department.
The approval is limited. According to the letter as quoted by Religion News Service, Durman may still need to attend meetings where AI is used and submit materials through systems that use AI. The university told TechCrunch that “an accommodation could be provided while allowing the employee to continue performing the essential functions of their position.” It also said accommodations may be reviewed as jobs change.
Infographic 01 · University of Kentucky · 2026
One letter, one meeting, one narrow exemption.
A Humanist research administrator asked not to use AI himself. His employer, which rolled out Copilot campus-wide, said yes.
- 31 Jul 2026Copilot promoted for meeting notesAt a department meeting, per Durman’s letter. Chatbots suggested, internal AI tools in development.
- 24 AugTwo-page letter to the Office of Equal OpportunityRequest under Title VII, drafted with the American Humanist Association. “Using AI or LLM tools is not an essential function of my position.”
- Mid-SepOne meetingDurman and the AHA’s staff attorney meet university officials. “A very collegial meeting.”
- 25 SepApproved“No undue burden on his department,” per the AHA. No lawsuit, no court, no precedent.
- 26 to 29 OctMade publicAHA, Religion News Service, then TechCrunch.
Excused
- Personal use of AI or LLM tools to complete his own tasks
- AI note-taking: he takes and shares his own notes
Still expected
- Taking part in meetings that use AI
- Submitting materials through systems that use AI
- Same duties; colleagues keep using AI
- May be reviewed “as technology and job responsibilities evolve”
“David is excused from personal use of AI to complete his tasks.”University approval letter, as quoted by Religion News Service. The letter itself is not public.
Sources: Durman letter, 24 Aug 2026; AHA press release, 26 Oct 2026; RNS, 26 Oct 2026 (quotes the approval letter); TechCrunch, 29 Oct 2026 (university statement). Timeline and layout: Thorsten Meyer.
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
How the Accommodation Could Apply
The case shows how existing workplace discrimination law may apply when an employee’s religious or ethical convictions conflict with an employer’s AI-use policy. Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, covered employers generally must accommodate sincerely held religious beliefs unless doing so would create an undue hardship. Federal regulations include certain moral or ethical beliefs held with the strength of traditional religious views; belief in a deity is not required.
That does not mean a worker has a general right to reject any technology. The accommodation depends on the individual’s belief, the actual requirements of the job and whether an adjustment can be made without undue hardship. Durman said AI use was not an essential function of his position and offered an alternative. An employee whose work depends on AI systems could face a different assessment.
The issue matters as employers introduce AI into routine tasks and decide whether its use is optional or mandatory. A worker who believes using a tool conflicts with a protected belief may have a process for seeking an adjustment, but the Kentucky decision does not settle how other employers must respond.
Products Worth Considering

Apple MacBook Air 15-inch Laptop with M5 Chip, 16GB Memory, 512GB SSD, Midnight

Apple AirPods Pro (2nd Generation) Wireless Earbuds with USB-C MagSafe Charging Case

Bose QuietComfort True Wireless Earbuds with Active Noise Cancellation, Bluetooth 5.3, USB-C Charging, IPX4, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Legal Test and Its Limits
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s regulation, 29 C.F.R. § 1605.1, says religious beliefs can include moral or ethical beliefs about right and wrong when sincerely held with the strength of traditional religious views. The source account notes that political views and personal preferences, by themselves, are not covered by this standard. Whether a particular belief qualifies depends on the circumstances; a label alone does not decide the question.
Title VII applies to employers with 15 or more employees. The Supreme Court clarified the undue-hardship standard in its 2023 decision in Groff v. DeJoy: an employer denying an accommodation must show substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business. The source account says coworker dislike is not enough and employers must consider alternatives.
The Kentucky decision followed an internal accommodation request, with no lawsuit. It therefore creates no court precedent. The AHA says Durman is the first Humanist to receive such an accommodation, but that is the organization’s characterization. Business Insider previously reported that Erin Maus, a Unitarian Universalist software engineer in North Carolina, received an AI-related religious exemption in May 2026.
““I believe that our capacity to think and reason for ourselves is worth protecting.””
— David Durman, in a statement cited by the American Humanist Association
Questions Beyond Durman’s Job
The available reporting does not include the university’s full accommodation file or a detailed account of how it assessed department costs. It is also unclear whether Durman will be asked to use AI in future duties, or how the university would review the accommodation if his responsibilities change. The university said accommodations may be reviewed as jobs change.
There has been no court decision on Durman’s request, and the approval does not bind other employers. The source material also does not establish whether every objection to AI could qualify as a religious belief under Title VII. Each request would turn on its own facts, including the sincerity and nature of the belief, the job’s essential functions and the employer’s evidence about hardship.
How Employers May Respond
The immediate next step is at the workplace: the university may revisit Durman’s arrangement if his role or the tools required for it change. For other employees, the case offers an example of asking for an accommodation before AI use becomes a job requirement, but not a guarantee of approval. Workers considering a request can describe the conflict, identify affected tasks and propose a way to complete essential duties without personally using the tool.
Employers assessing similar requests will need to consider the specific belief and job rather than treat the Kentucky outcome as a universal rule. Whether disputes over AI accommodations reach courts remains unclear. Any future rulings, agency guidance or changes in employer policies could clarify how the existing legal standards apply as workplace AI use expands.
Key Questions
Can an employee legally refuse to use AI at work?
Sometimes an employee may qualify for a workplace accommodation, but there is no automatic right to refuse AI. Under Title VII, covered employers must accommodate qualifying sincerely held religious beliefs unless doing so would create undue hardship. The answer depends on the worker’s circumstances and job.
Can a Humanist or atheist request a religious accommodation?
Federal employment rules do not require belief in a god for a belief to count as religious. Certain sincerely held moral or ethical beliefs may qualify if held with the strength of traditional religious views. Whether a particular belief meets that standard depends on the facts.
Does the Kentucky decision create a legal precedent?
No. The University of Kentucky approved an individual accommodation through its equal-opportunity office. There was no lawsuit or court ruling, so the decision does not establish a rule for other employers.
Does the accommodation let Durman avoid every AI system?
No. The approval exempts him from personally using AI, according to reporting on the letter. He may still have to attend meetings where AI is used or submit information through AI-enabled systems. The university said accommodations may be reviewed as job duties change.
What does undue hardship mean for an employer?
Under the Supreme Court’s 2023 Groff v. DeJoy decision, an employer denying a religious accommodation must show substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business. The employer’s assessment depends on the specific request and workplace.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
